• Account Subscribe Donate

• Home
• About
• Chapters
• 
• Issues
• Support
• Contact

CAPR Candidate Ratings

view Outstanding ALL CAPR Rated		State California Washington No Items	Jurisdiction ALL *STATEWIDE* ADAMS ASOTIN BENTON CHELAN CLALLAM CLARK	District ALL No Items	Locality ALL No Items	Office ALL No Items
Change Jurisdiction above to view your county's candidates.				Washington Primary Aug 04,2020		as of 2019-11-25 19:05:28

Washington *STATEWIDE*
Congressional District 1			Donate to CAPR PAC
	U.S. Representative 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Suzan DelBene Not Rated by CAPR Steven Skelton Not Rated by CAPR Robert Dean Mair Not Rated by CAPR Matthew Heines Not Rated by CAPR Justin Smoak Not Rated by CAPR Derek Chartrand Not Rated by CAPR Jeffrey Beeler, Sr. Not Rated by CAPR
Congressional District 10			Donate to CAPR PAC
	U.S. Representative 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Jackson Maynard Not Rated by CAPR Beth Doglio Not Rated by CAPR Don Hewett Not Rated by CAPR Phil Gardner Not Rated by CAPR Eric LeMay Not Rated by CAPR Marilyn Strickland Not Rated by CAPR Dean Johnson Not Rated by CAPR Ryan Tate Not Rated by CAPR Ralph Johnson Not Rated by CAPR Sam Wright Not Rated by CAPR Randolph (Randy) Bell Not Rated by CAPR Todd Buckley Not Rated by CAPR Nancy Dailey Slotnick Not Rated by CAPR Kristine M. Reeves Not Rated by CAPR Joshua Collins Not Rated by CAPR Rian Ingrim Not Rated by CAPR Gordon Allen Pross Not Rated by CAPR Richard Boyce Not Rated by CAPR Mary Bacon Not Rated by CAPR
Congressional District 2			Donate to CAPR PAC
	U.S. Representative 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Timothy S. Hazelo Not Rated by CAPR Tim Uy Not Rated by CAPR Kari Ilonummi Not Rated by CAPR Rick Larsen Not Rated by CAPR James Dean Golder Not Rated by CAPR Carrie R. Kennedy Not Rated by CAPR Cody Hart Not Rated by CAPR Jason Call Not Rated by CAPR
Congressional District 3			Donate to CAPR PAC
	U.S. Representative 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Martin D. Hash Not Rated by CAPR Davy Ray Not Rated by CAPR Carolyn Long Not Rated by CAPR Devin C. Gray Not Rated by CAPR Jaime Herrera Beutler Not Rated by CAPR
CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICT 4			Donate to CAPR PAC
	U.S. Representative 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Ryan Cooper Not Rated by CAPR Tracy "Justice" Wright Not Rated by CAPR Douglas E. McKinley Not Rated by CAPR Evan Jones Not Rated by CAPR Sarena Sloot Not Rated by CAPR Dan Newhouse Not Rated by CAPR
CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICT 5			Donate to CAPR PAC
	U.S. Representative 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Chris Armitage Not Rated by CAPR Brendan O'Regan Not Rated by CAPR Stephen T. Major Not Rated by CAPR Dave Wilson Not Rated by CAPR Cathy McMorris Rodgers Not Rated by CAPR
Congressional District 6			Donate to CAPR PAC
	U.S. Representative 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Elizabeth Kreiselmaier Not Rated by CAPR Chris Welton Not Rated by CAPR Rebecca Parson Not Rated by CAPR Stephan Brodhead Not Rated by CAPR Johny Alberg Not Rated by CAPR Derek Kilmer Not Rated by CAPR
Congressional District 7			Donate to CAPR PAC
	U.S. Representative 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Scott Sutherland Not Rated by CAPR Jack Hughes-Hageman Not Rated by CAPR Pramila Jayapal Not Rated by CAPR Rick Lewis Not Rated by CAPR Craig Keller Not Rated by CAPR
Congressional District 8			Donate to CAPR PAC
	U.S. Representative 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting James Mitchell Not Rated by CAPR Corey Bailey Not Rated by CAPR Jesse Jensen Not Rated by CAPR Kim Schrier Not Rated by CAPR Ryan Dean Burkett Not Rated by CAPR Dave Saulibio Not Rated by CAPR Keith Arnold Not Rated by CAPR Keith R. Swank Not Rated by CAPR
Congressional District 9			Donate to CAPR PAC
	U.S. Representative 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Jorge Besada Not Rated by CAPR Joshua Campbell Not Rated by CAPR Doug Basler Not Rated by CAPR Adam Smith Not Rated by CAPR
ADAMS SUPERIOR COURT			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position 1 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Steve Dixon Not Rated by CAPR
Asotin, Columbia, Garfield Superior Court			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position 1 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Brooke J. Burns Not Rated by CAPR G. Scott Marinella Not Rated by CAPR R. Victor Bottomly Not Rated by CAPR
Benton, Franklin Superior Court			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position 1 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Talesha "Tali" Sams Not Rated by CAPR Shelley A. Ajax Not Rated by CAPR Bronson J. Brown Not Rated by CAPR Dave Petersen Not Rated by CAPR Sharon Brown Not Rated by CAPR Shawn P. Sant Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 2 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Joe Burrowes Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 3 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Alexander Carl Ekstrom Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 4 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Cameron Mitchell Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 5 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Sam Swanberg Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 6 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Carrie Runge Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 7 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Jacqueline Shea Brown Not Rated by CAPR
CHELAN SUPERIOR COURT			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position 1 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Lesley A. Allan Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 2 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Travis Brandt Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 3 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Kristin Ferrera Not Rated by CAPR
CLALLAM SUPERIOR COURT			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position 1 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Lauren Erickson Not Rated by CAPR Lisa N. Dublin Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 2 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Simon Barnhart Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 3 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Brent Basden Not Rated by CAPR
Clark Superior Court			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Department No. 1 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Daniel L. Stahnke Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Department No. 10 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Scott A. Collier Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Department No. 2 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting David E. Gregerson Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Department No. 3 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Derek J. Vanderwood Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Department No. 4 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Gregory M. Gonzales Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Department No. 5 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Bernard F. Veljacic Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Department No. 6 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting John Fairgrieve Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Department No. 7 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Jennifer K. Snider Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Department No. 8 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Suzan L. Clark Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Department No. 9 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Robert A. Lewis Not Rated by CAPR
Court of Appeals, Division 1, District 1			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position 5 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting David S. Mann Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 6 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Bill Bowman Not Rated by CAPR
Court of Appeals, Division 1, District 2			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position 2 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Linda Coburn Not Rated by CAPR
Court of Appeals, Division 2, District 1			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position 2 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Lisa Worswick Not Rated by CAPR
Court of Appeals, Division 2, District 2			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position 1 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Lisa L. Sutton Not Rated by CAPR
Court of Appeals, Division 3, District 1			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position 2 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Marshall Casey Not Rated by CAPR Tracy Arlene Staab Not Rated by CAPR
Court of Appeals, Division 3, District 3			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position 1 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Rebecca Pennell Not Rated by CAPR
Cowlitz Superior Court			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position 1 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Gary Bashor Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 2 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Thad E. Scudder Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 3 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Michael H. Evans Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 4 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Marilyn K. Haan Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 5 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Patricia M. Fassett Not Rated by CAPR
Douglas Superior Court			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position 1 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Brian C. Huber Not Rated by CAPR
Ferry, Pend Oreille, Stevens Superior Court			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position 1 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Patrick A. Monasmith Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 2 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Jessica Taylor Reeves Not Rated by CAPR
GRANT SUPERIOR COURT			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position #01 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting David Estudillo Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position #02 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting John D Knodell Not Rated by CAPR Kevin J McCrae Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position #03 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting John Antosz Not Rated by CAPR
GRAYS HARBOR SUPERIOR COURT			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position 1 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Katie Svoboda Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 2 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting David L. Edwards Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 3 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting David Mistachkin Not Rated by CAPR
ISLAND SUPERIOR COURT			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position 1 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Christon C. Skinner Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 2 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Kathleen Petrich Not Rated by CAPR Carolyn Cliff Not Rated by CAPR
Jefferson Superior Court			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position 1 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Keith C. Harper Not Rated by CAPR
King Superior Court			Donate to CAPR PAC
	Judge Position 1 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting David J. Whedbee Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 10 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Regina S. Cahan Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 11 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Catherine Shaffer Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 12 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Dean S. Lum Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 13 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Hillary Madsen Not Rated by CAPR Andrea Robertson Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 14 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Nicole Gaines Phelps Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 15 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Samuel S. Chung Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 16 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Averil B. Rothrock Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 17 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Josephine Wiggs-Martin Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 18 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Susan J. Craighead Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 19 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Nelson K. H. Lee Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 2 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting David A. Steiner Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 20 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Susan H. Amini Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 21 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Veronica Galván Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 22 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Karen Donohue Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 23 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Andrea A. Darvas Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 24 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Patrick H. Oishi Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 25 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Elizabeth Berns Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 26 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting David Keenan Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 27 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Tanya L. Thorp Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 28 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Johanna Bender Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 29 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Sean Patrick O'Donnell Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 3 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Julie Ann Spector Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 30 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Doug North Not Rated by CAPR Carolyn Ladd Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 31 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Marshall Ferguson Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 32 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting LeRoy McCullough Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 33 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Steven Rosen Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 34 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting A. Chad Allred Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 35 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Mafé Rajul Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 36 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Annette M. Messitt Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 37 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Michael Ryan Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 38 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting J. Michael "Mike" Diaz Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 39 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Julia Garratt Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 4 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Mary E. Roberts Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 40 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Ken Schubert Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 41 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Matt Williams Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 42 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Sue Parisien Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 43 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting John McHale Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 44 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Catherine Moore Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 45 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting James E. (Jim) Rogers Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 46 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Judith Ramseyer Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 47 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Roger Rogoff Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 48 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Brian McDonald Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 49 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Aimee Sutton Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 5 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Maureen McKee Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 50 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Ketu Shah Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 51 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Cindi Port Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 52 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Kristin Richardson Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 53 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Sandra Widlan Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 6 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Melinda J. Young Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 7 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Janet Helson Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 8 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting John R. Ruhl Not Rated by CAPR
	Judge Position 9 0 votes counted as of
		Name (CAPRPAC rating) Party Pri Votes % of vote/place Ratting Michael Scott Not Rated by CAPR
Click Next for more Races

Outstanding

Good

Fair

Poor

DATA Print Opposed

Copyright 2009 Citizens' Alliance for Property Rights (powered by Chuck)